Unit 2: India and the Major Powers
Table of Contents
1. India and the USA: From "Estranged Democracies" to Strategic Partners
The relationship between the world's oldest democracy (USA) and the world's largest democracy (India) has shifted from deep suspicion during the Cold War to a Comprehensive Global Strategic Partnership today.
The Cold War Era (1947-1991)
During this period, relations were often strained:
- Non-Alignment: The US viewed India's non-alignment as "immoral" or pro-Soviet.
- The Pakistan Factor: The US military alliance with Pakistan (SEATO/CENTO) and its support for Pakistan during the 1971 war created deep distrust.
- Nuclear Issues: India's nuclear test in 1974 (Smiling Buddha) led to US sanctions and technology denial.
The Post-Cold War Turnaround (1991-Present)
After the collapse of the USSR and India's economic liberalization, the relationship warmed up significantly:
- Nuclear Deal (2008): The 123 Agreement effectively recognized India as a nuclear power, ending India's "nuclear isolation."
- Defense Cooperation: India now conducts more military exercises with the US than with any other country. The US has designated India as a "Major Defense Partner."
- The China Factor: Shared concerns about China's rise in the Indo-Pacific have brought the two nations closer through the QUAD (India, US, Japan, Australia).
2. India and Russia (formerly USSR)
Russia has traditionally been described as India’s "all-weather friend." The relationship is built on mutual trust, defense cooperation, and geopolitical balance.
The Soviet Legacy
- 1971 Treaty: The Indo-Soviet Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Cooperation was a turning point, providing India with security against the US-China-Pakistan axis during the Bangladesh Liberation War.
- Economic Support: The USSR helped India build its heavy industries (Bhilai, Bokaro Steel Plants) when the West was reluctant.
- The Veto: The USSR/Russia has frequently used its veto in the UN Security Council to protect India's interests, especially on the Kashmir issue.
Contemporary Relations (Post-1991)
- Defense: Russia remains India's largest arms supplier (e.g., S-400 Missile System, BrahMos missiles).
- Energy: Strong cooperation in nuclear energy (Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant) and oil/gas investments.
- Strategic Autonomy: India maintains its tie with Russia despite Western pressure (e.g., during the Ukraine conflict), highlighting its independent foreign policy.
3. Comparative View: USA vs. Russia
| Aspect | India-USA Relations | India-Russia Relations |
|---|---|---|
| Main Drivers | Technology, Trade, Diaspora, China Factor | Defense, Energy, Geopolitical Trust |
| History | "Estranged" (Cold War) to "Engaged" | Consistent "All-weather" Friendship |
| Trade | India's largest trading partner | Focus on specific sectors (Arms/Energy) |
| Diaspora | Huge influential Indian-American community | Minimal diaspora influence |
4. Major Strategic Milestones
To understand current dynamics, keep these key agreements in mind:
- BECA, LEMOA, COMCASA: Foundation agreements signed with the US that allow for deeper military interoperability and intelligence sharing.
- S-400 Deal: A $5 billion deal with Russia for air-defense systems, showing India's willingness to defy US "CAATSA" sanctions to maintain its Russian link.
5. Exam Focus: Tips and FAQs
Exam Tips
- Balance: When writing about major powers, emphasize India's Balancing Act. India wants the US's technology but Russia's geopolitical support.
- Indian Diaspora: Mention the role of the 4 million Indian-Americans in shaping US policy toward India.
- Veto: Always mention the USSR's use of the Veto in 1971; it's a classic example of "tried and tested" friendship.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What was the "Tilt" in US policy in 1971?
A: The US "tilted" toward Pakistan during the 1971 war, even sending the USS Enterprise (7th Fleet) into the Bay of Bengal to intimidate India.
Q: Is India moving away from Russia toward the US?
A: While India is diversifying its arms purchases and joining the QUAD, it continues to view Russia as a vital partner for continental security and energy.
End of Unit 2 Notes | Prepared for DSC 353 | Knowlet