FYUG Odd Semester Exam, 2023 (Held in 2024)
PHILOSOPHY: PHIDSC-101T
Epistemology and Metaphysics (Indian)

Subject: Philosophy

Paper Code: PHIDSC-101T

Full Marks: 70 | Pass Marks: 28

Time Duration: 3 Hours


SECTION-A: Short Answer Questions

Answer any ten questions, selecting two from each Unit. (Total: 20 Marks)

UNIT-I

[2 Marks]

Q1. Mention the orthodox systems of Indian philosophy.

The six orthodox (Astika) systems of Indian philosophy, which accept the authority of the Vedas, are:

  • Nyaya
  • Vaisheshika
  • Samkhya
  • Yoga
  • Mimamsa
  • Vedanta
[2 Marks]

Q2. What do you mean by Upanisadic concept of Atmana?

The Upanisadic concept of Atman refers to the inner self or soul of an individual. It is considered the eternal, unchanging essence that is identical with the ultimate reality, Brahman.

[2 Marks]

Q3. Mention two orthodox systems which do not believe in God.

Two orthodox systems that traditionally do not posit a creator God are:

  • Samkhya (Classical Samkhya is atheistic/Nirishvara).
  • Mimamsa (Focuses on Dharma and Vedic rituals over a personal deity).

UNIT-II

[2 Marks]

Q4. Why, according to Carvaka, Vyapti is not possible?

According to Carvaka, Vyapti (universal concomitance) is not possible because it cannot be established through perception. Since we cannot perceive all cases of a relationship in the past, present, and future, any universal rule is an unjustified leap.

[2 Marks]

Q5. What are the elements of which material objects of the world composed?

In Indian materialism (Carvaka), material objects are composed of four elements:

  • Ksit (Earth)
  • Ap (Water)
  • Tejas (Fire)
  • Marut (Air)

Note: Akasha (Ether) is rejected because it is not perceivable.

[2 Marks]

Q6. How many kinds of judgement are there in Jaina system?

In the Jaina system of Syadvada, there are seven kinds of conditional judgements (Saptabhangi Naya). These represent different perspectives (Nayas) through which truth is expressed.

UNIT-III

[2 Marks]

Q7. What are the four major schools of Buddhism?

The four major schools of Buddhism are:

  • Vaibhasika (Direct Realism)
  • Sautrantika (Indirect Realism)
  • Yogacara/Vijnanavada (Idealism)
  • Madhyamika/Sunyavada (Voidness/Nihilism)
[2 Marks]

Q8. What is Nirvana in Buddhistic philosophy?

Nirvana is the ultimate goal of Buddhism, representing the cessation of suffering (Dukkha) and the cycle of rebirth. It is the "blowing out" of the fires of greed, hatred, and delusion.

[2 Marks]

Q9. What are the twelve links in the chain of causation?

The twelve links (Bhavacakra) in the Pratityasamutpada are:

  1. Avidya (Ignorance)
  2. Samskara (Impressions)
  3. Vijnana (Consciousness)
  4. Nama-rupa (Mind-Body)
  5. Sadayatana (Six Sense Organs)
  6. Sparsa (Contact)
  7. Vedana (Sensation)
  8. Trsna (Crave)
  9. Upadana (Attachment)
  10. Bhava (Becoming)
  11. Jati (Birth)
  12. Jara-marana (Old age and Death)

UNIT-IV

[2 Marks]

Q10. Who is the founder of Vaisesika system? Write the name of the book written by him.

The founder of the Vaisesika system is Maharsi Kanada. The foundational text written by him is the Vaisesika Sutra.

[2 Marks]

Q11. What is Svarthanumana?

Svarthanumana is inference for oneself. It is the psychological process where an individual reaches a conclusion for their own conviction without the need for formal steps to convince others.

[2 Marks]

Q12. What is Vyapti?

Vyapti is the relation of invariable and unconditional concomitance between the middle term (Hetu) and the major term (Sadhya). It is the logical ground of inference.

UNIT-V

[2 Marks]

Q13. Name two major schools of Vedanta.

Two major schools of Vedanta are:

  • Advaita Vedanta (Shankara)
  • Visistadvaita Vedanta (Ramanuja)
[2 Marks]

Q14. What are the two eternal realities of Samkhya?

The two eternal, independent, and ultimate realities in Samkhya philosophy are:

  • Purusa (Pure Consciousness)
  • Prakrti (Primal Matter/Nature)
[2 Marks]

Q15. What are the two functions of Maya in Sankara's philosophy?

In Sankara's Advaita Vedanta, Maya has two functions:

  • Avarana-sakti: The power to conceal the true nature of reality (Brahman).
  • Viksepa-sakti: The power to project the phenomenal world of multiplicity.

SECTION-B: Descriptive Answer Questions

Answer five questions, selecting one from each Unit. (Total: 50 Marks)

UNIT-I

[10 Marks]

Q16. Give a brief note on the Schools of Indian philosophy.

Indian philosophy (Darshana) is broadly divided into two categories based on their acceptance of Vedic authority:

1. Heterodox Schools (Nastika)

These schools reject the authority of the Vedas:

  • Carvaka: A materialistic school that believes only in perception.
  • Buddhism: Founded by Gautama Buddha, focusing on the Four Noble Truths and Nirvana.
  • Jainism: Emphasizes Ahimsa, Anekantavada (relativity of truth), and the liberation of the Jiva.

2. Orthodox Schools (Astika)

These six schools (Saddarsana) accept Vedic authority:

  • Nyaya: Focuses on logic and epistemology.
  • Vaisesika: Known for its atomic theory and categorization of reality (Padarthas).
  • Samkhya: A dualistic school emphasizing the separation of Purusa and Prakrti.
  • Yoga: Focuses on the practical path of meditation and mind control.
  • Mimamsa: Concerned with the ritualistic interpretation of the Vedas.
  • Vedanta: The "end of the Vedas," focusing on the nature of Brahman and Atman.
[10 Marks]

Q17. State and explain the distinctive features of Indian philosophy.

Indian philosophy possesses several unique characteristics:

  • Practical Necessity: It is not merely an intellectual exercise but a way of life aimed at removing suffering.
  • Spiritual Orientation: Most schools seek Moksha (liberation) from the cycle of birth and death.
  • The Law of Karma: The belief that every action has a moral consequence.
  • The Cycle of Rebirth (Samsara): The soul undergoes multiple births until it achieves liberation.
  • Pessimism to Optimism: While starting with the realization of suffering (pessimism), it ends with the possibility of eternal peace (optimism).
  • Faith in the Past: Most schools show reverence for ancient texts (Vedas/Agamas).

UNIT-II

[2+8=10 Marks]

Q18. Why does Carvaka reject the existence of God? Discuss Carvaka critique of inference.

Part A: Rejection of God

Carvaka rejects God because God cannot be perceived. According to their epistemology, Pratyaksa (perception) is the only valid source of knowledge. Since God is neither visible nor detectable through any sense organ, God's existence is a myth created by priests for their own benefit.

Part B: Critique of Inference (Anumana)

Carvaka argues that inference is not a valid Pramana for the following reasons:

  • Lack of Universal Relation (Vyapti): Inference depends on Vyapti (smoke implies fire). Carvaka asks: How do we know this relation is universal?
  • Perception is Limited: We can perceive individual cases of smoke and fire, but we cannot perceive all cases in all times and places.
  • Circular Reasoning: If we use another inference to prove Vyapti, it leads to an infinite regress (Anavastha).
Conclusion: For Carvaka, inference provides only a probability, not certain knowledge.
[10 Marks]

Q19. Explain and examine Jaina theory of Syadvada.

Syadvada is the Jaina theory of the relativity of knowledge. It suggests that all judgements are true only under certain conditions or from a particular standpoint (Naya).

The Seven-fold Judgement (Saptabhangi Naya):

  1. Syad Asti: Relatively, a thing exists.
  2. Syad Nasti: Relatively, a thing does not exist.
  3. Syad Asti Nasti: Relatively, it exists and does not exist.
  4. Syad Avaktavyam: Relatively, it is indescribable.
  5. Syad Asti ca Avaktavyam: Relatively, it exists and is indescribable.
  6. Syad Nasti ca Avaktavyam: Relatively, it does not exist and is indescribable.
  7. Syad Asti Nasti ca Avaktavyam: Relatively, it exists, does not exist, and is indescribable.

Critical Examination: While Syadvada promotes intellectual tolerance (Anekantavada), critics like Sankara argue it leads to skepticism and contradiction.

UNIT-III

[2+8=10 Marks]

Q20. Is there any permanent Self according to Buddha? Explain Niratmavada as a theory of Self according to Buddha.

Part A: Permanent Self

No, Buddha explicitly rejected the existence of a permanent, eternal, and unchanging soul (Atman).

Part B: Niratmavada (Anatta)

Niratmavada is the doctrine of "No-Self." Buddha argued that what we call the "Self" is actually a collection of five changing aggregates (Skandhas):

  • Rupa: Matter/Body
  • Vedana: Feelings/Sensation
  • Samjna: Perception
  • Samskara: Mental dispositions
  • Vijnana: Consciousness

Just as a chariot is a name for a collection of parts (wheels, axle, etc.), the "Self" is a conventional name for these ever-changing processes.

[10 Marks]

Q21. Does Buddha believe in Universal Law of Causation (Pratityasamutpada)? Explain.

Yes, Pratityasamutpada is the foundation of Buddha’s teachings. It means "Dependent Origination"—that everything arises in dependence on causes and conditions.

Formula: "This being, that arises; on the cessation of this, that ceases."

This law explains:

  • The Cause of Suffering: Explained through the 12 links (Nidanas).
  • Impermanence (Anicca): Since everything is caused, everything must pass away.
  • Middle Path: It avoids the extremes of eternalism and nihilism.

UNIT-IV

[2+3+5=10 Marks]

Q22. What is perception according to Nyaya philosophy? Mention different kinds of perception. Distinguish between determinate and indeterminate perception.

Definition:

According to Nyaya, perception (Pratyaksa) is the "definite knowledge that arises from the contact of a sense organ with an object."

Kinds of Perception:

  • Laukika (Ordinary): Contact between senses and objects.
  • Alaukika (Extraordinary): Includes Samanyalaksana, Jnanalaksana, and Yogaja.

Determinate (Savikalpaka) vs. Indeterminate (Nirvikalpaka):

Feature Nirvikalpaka (Indeterminate) Savikalpaka (Determinate)
Nature Raw sensing without names or categories. Knowledge involving name, class, and quality.
Description Cannot be expressed in words. Can be articulated (e.g., "That is a red apple").
[10 Marks]

Q23. Discuss in detail the Vaisesikas four kinds of Abhava.

Abhava refers to non-existence. Vaisesika classifies it into four types:

  1. Pragabhava (Antecedent non-existence): The non-existence of a thing before its production (e.g., non-existence of a pot in the clay).
  2. Pradhvamsabhava (Posterior non-existence): The non-existence of a thing after its destruction (e.g., when a pot is broken).
  3. Atyantabhava (Absolute non-existence): The absence of a relation between two things for all time (e.g., "the son of a barren woman" or "color in air").
  4. Anyonyabhava (Mutual non-existence): The fact that one thing is not another thing (e.g., "A jar is not a cloth").

UNIT-V

[2+7+1=10 Marks]

Q24. What is Purusa? How does Samkhya prove the existence of Purusa? Is Purusa one or many?

Definition:

Purusa is the pure consciousness, eternal, and inactive witness in Samkhya philosophy.

Proofs for the existence of Purusa:

  • Teleological Argument: All material objects (Prakrti) exist for the sake of someone else (Purusa).
  • Control Argument: Matter must be controlled by a conscious agent.
  • Enjoyment Argument: There must be an enjoyer of the modifications of Prakrti.
  • Aspiration for Liberation: The desire to be free implies a conscious being who can be free.

Plurality of Purusa:

Samkhya believes that Purusa is Many (Plurality of Selves) because different individuals have different births, deaths, and experiences.

[10 Marks]

Q25. Explain critically Advaita doctrine of Maya.

In Advaita Vedanta, Maya is the power of Brahman that makes the one appear as many.

Characteristics:

  • Anirvacaniya: It is neither real (Sat) nor unreal (Asat); it is indescribable.
  • Beginningless (Anadi): It has no start, but it ends with the realization of Brahman.
  • Subjective and Objective: It conceals reality and projects the world.

Critical View: Critics (like Ramanuja) ask: Where does Maya reside? If it resides in Brahman, Brahman's purity is compromised. If in Jiva, Jiva itself is a product of Maya.