FYUG Odd Semester Exam, 2023 (Held in 2024)
PHILOSOPHY: PHIDSC-102T
Epistemology and Metaphysics: Western

Subject: Philosophy (Western)
Paper Code: PHIDSC-102T
Course Type: 1st Semester (FYUG)
Full Marks: 70
Time: 3 Hours
Pass Marks: 28

SECTION-A: Short Answer Questions

Answer ten questions, selecting two from each Unit. (Total: 20 Marks)

UNIT-I

2 Marks

Q1. What is epistemology?

Epistemology is the branch of philosophy that investigates the nature, origin, scope, and limits of human knowledge. It seeks to answer fundamental questions such as "How do we know?" and "What is truth?"

2 Marks

Q2. What is ontology? Is ontology synonymous with metaphysics?

Ontology is the branch of metaphysics dealing with the nature of being and existence. While often used interchangeably, they are not strictly synonymous; Metaphysics is the broader field, while Ontology is the specific sub-field focused exclusively on what "entities" exist.

2 Marks

Q3. What are the main branches of philosophy? Which branch of philosophy is dealt with value?

The main branches are Epistemology, Metaphysics, Ethics, and Logic. The branch that deals with values is Axiology (which includes Ethics and Aesthetics).

UNIT-II

2 Marks

Q4. How many types of knowledge are there according to Plato? Name them.

According to Plato's "Analogy of the Divided Line," there are four levels/types of knowledge: Eikasia (Imagination), Pistis (Belief), Dianoia (Mathematical reasoning), and Noesis (Pure Dialectic/Intelligence).

2 Marks

Q5. Name two dialogues of Plato in which he talked about theory of knowledge.

Plato discusses his theory of knowledge extensively in The Republic and Theaetetus.

2 Marks

Q6. How many realities are there according to Aristotle? Name them.

Aristotle emphasizes a single, unified reality where Form and Matter coexist in individual substances. He rejects Plato's dualism, focusing instead on the reality of the physical world and its categorized substances.

UNIT-III

1+1=2 Marks

Q7. What, according to empiricism, is the source of knowledge? Name one modern empiricist philosopher.

According to empiricism, the sole source of knowledge is Sense Experience. A prominent modern empiricist philosopher is John Locke.

1+1=2 Marks

Q8. Who is the author of the book, Critique of Pure Reason? What kind of revolution did he bring in philosophy?

The author is Immanuel Kant. He introduced the Copernican Revolution in philosophy, which shifted the focus from the object to the subject, arguing that the mind actively shapes our experience.

2 Marks

Q9. How does John Locke refute the Doctrine of Innate ideas? Mention two grounds.

Locke refutes innate ideas on two primary grounds: (1) Lack of universal consent (children and idiots do not possess them), and (2) The mind is initially a Tabula Rasa (blank slate) filled only by experience.

UNIT-IV

2 Marks

Q10. Why is Locke's theory of realism called representationalism?

It is called representationalism because he argues that we do not perceive objects directly; rather, the mind perceives ideas which "represent" the external objects.

1+1=2 Marks

Q11. Write two points of difference between realism and idealism.

  • Realism: Believes the external world exists independently of the mind.
  • Idealism: Claims that reality is mentally constructed or dependent on the mind.
1+1=2 Marks

Q12. "Whatever is rational is real and whatever is real is rational." Who said this? Name the theory associated with him.

This was said by G.W.F. Hegel. The associated theory is Absolute Idealism.

UNIT-V

2 Marks

Q13. What do you mean by conceptual time?

Conceptual time refers to time as an abstract, mathematical construction or a mental framework used to order events, as opposed to time as a physical, external entity.

2 Marks

Q14. "Space and Time are empirically real but transcendentally ideal." Who said this? Why did he say so?

Immanuel Kant said this. He believed space and time are the necessary forms of our intuition (transcendentally ideal) through which all objects are perceived (empirically real).

2 Marks

Q15. What is the popular view of causality?

The popular view of causality is the "Necessary Connection" theory—the belief that there is a power or force in the cause that produces the effect by necessity.


SECTION-B: Descriptive Answer Questions

Answer five questions, selecting one from each Unit. (Total: 50 Marks)

UNIT-I

2+4+4=10 Marks

Q16. What is philosophy? Discuss the nature and scope of philosophy.

Definition:

Philosophy literally means "love of wisdom" (Philo + Sophia). It is the critical and systematic study of the most fundamental questions of existence.

Nature:

  • Critical: It does not accept anything without rational questioning.
  • Comprehensive: It looks at the whole of reality rather than specific segments.
  • Normative: It deals with how things "ought" to be.

Scope:

The scope of philosophy extends to every aspect of human life, including the study of the universe (Metaphysics), knowledge (Epistemology), values (Axiology), and reasoning (Logic).

4+6=10 Marks

Q17. Elucidate upon the concept of applied philosophy. Explain the areas in which practical application of philosophical knowledge is seen.

Applied philosophy is the practical use of philosophical methods and theories to solve real-world problems.

Key Areas of Application:

  • Applied Ethics: Includes Bioethics (medical), Environmental ethics, and Business ethics.
  • Philosophy of Law: Examines justice and legal systems.
  • Political Philosophy: Applies concepts of rights and democracy to governance.
  • Philosophy of Education: Shapes curriculum and teaching methods.

UNIT-II

1+1+8=10 Marks

Q18. What, according to Plato is the ultimate reality? Can the 'Ideas' of Plato be known by experience? Explain Plato's theory of Ideas.

Ultimate Reality:

For Plato, the ultimate reality is the World of Ideas (or Forms). These are eternal, unchanging, and perfect archetypes of all things.

Knowledge by Experience:

No, Ideas cannot be known by sense experience. Experience only provides "opinion" of the shadows of reality. Ideas are known only through Reason.

Theory of Ideas (Forms):

Plato argues that every object in the physical world is a mere imperfect copy of its perfect Form. For example, all beautiful things are beautiful only because they participate in the "Idea of Beauty".

2+8=10 Marks

Q19. What does Aristotle mean by cause? Explain Aristotle's theory of causation.

Aristotle identifies a "cause" as a factor necessary to explain why something is the way it is. He proposes the Four Causes:

  1. Material Cause: The substance of which something is made (e.g., Bronze of a statue).
  2. Formal Cause: The design or essence of the thing.
  3. Efficient Cause: The agent or force that brings it into being (e.g., the sculptor).
  4. Final Cause: The purpose or end for which it exists.

UNIT-III

7+3=10 Marks

Q20. Discuss rationalism as a theory of knowledge. What are the criticisms levelled against it?

Rationalism is the epistemological view that Reason is the primary source and test of knowledge. Famous proponents include Descartes, Spinoza, and Leibniz.

Key Features:

  • Emphasis on Innate Ideas.
  • Use of the Deductive Method.
  • Preference for mathematical certainty.

Criticisms:

Critics (Empiricists) argue that without sensory input, the mind remains empty. They also point out that many "innate" truths are actually learned through experience.

8+2=10 Marks

Q21. Explain Kant's critical theory of knowledge. Does the critical theory of Kant reconcile rationalism and empiricism?

Kant’s "Critique" argues that knowledge is a synthesis of both experience and reason.

"Thoughts without content are empty, intuitions without concepts are blind."

Reconciliation: Yes, he reconciles them by stating that Empiricism provides the raw data (sensations), while Rationalism provides the categories of the mind (space, time, causality) to organize that data.

UNIT-IV

1+7+2=10 Marks

Q22. Who coined the term 'Naive realism'? Discuss Naive realism as a theory of reality. What are the criticisms levelled against it?

Naive Realism is the "common sense" view that external objects exist exactly as we perceive them.

Key Tenets:

  • Direct perception of objects.
  • Objects possess primary and secondary qualities independently of the observer.

Criticisms:

The Argument from Illusion (e.g., a stick looks bent in water) and the Argument from Hallucination prove that perception is not always a direct or accurate reflection of reality.

1+1+8=10 Marks

Q23. What is solipsism? Was Berkeley a solipsist? Explain and examine Berkeley's theory of subjective idealism.

Definition:

Solipsism is the view that only one's own mind is sure to exist. Berkeley was NOT a solipsist because he believed in the existence of other minds and the Mind of God.

Subjective Idealism (Esse est Percipi):

Berkeley's central maxim is "To be is to be perceived". He argues that "material" objects are nothing but collections of ideas in the mind. Since ideas cannot exist outside a mind, the external world must be mental.

UNIT-V

10 Marks

Q24. Explain the different philosophical views on the nature of substance.

  • Descartes (Dualism): Three substances—God (infinite), Mind (thinking), and Matter (extended).
  • Spinoza (Monism): Only one substance exists—God or Nature.
  • Leibniz (Pluralism): Reality consists of infinite simple substances called Monads.
  • Locke: Substance is an "unknown somewhat" that supports qualities.
  • Hume: Rejects substance as a fiction; it is just a collection of impressions.
1+9=10 Marks

Q25. Does Hume believe that there is a necessary connection between cause and its effect? Critically examine Hume's theory of causation.

No, Hume argues that we never perceive a "necessary connection" between a cause and an effect.

Theory of Causation:

Hume reduces causation to Constant Conjunction. Because we always see event A followed by event B, our mind develops a "habit" or "custom" of expecting B when A occurs. Causality is a psychological expectation, not a logical or physical necessity.